Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
bosscrab

Mac Mini as NVR?

Recommended Posts

I have been thinking about using an older but recent Mac Mini as an NVR. It is a 2.3 ghz CoreI5 with 2gb ram.

 

I have 4 1.3 MP cameras.

 

Thinking about booting Windows 7 and using Blue Iris.

 

Thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Any i5 should handle those cams on Blue Iris with no problem, depending on frame rate and pre-trigger frames.

 

Later-gen i5s are better, of course - not sure which i5 you've got.

 

I'm just retiring an i3-540 that I've been running BI on for some time. It handles 6 cams, 6MP total, 10 fps, 25 pre-trigger frames, but won't handle another 1MP cam without choking when multiple cams are recording. My new i5-3570k handles double the MP with room to spare.

 

If you're not already there, you should check out www.cam-it.org, which is the Blue Iris community support forum. Lots of good info there, and many helpful users.

 

One suggestion - once you've got a BI version working the way you want it, don't upgrade to every new version that comes out, as bugs sometimes sneak in. I maintain a stable install until there's a compelling reason to upgrade to avoid unexpected problems.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let us know how this works out. I think a mini running Win7 should make a great BI PC. I see people spending much more than $600 for custom PCs, and they seem to be huge power hogs. My current AMD X6 700W works fine with multiple mp cams, but I am considering a mac mini due to size and power.

 

The form factor, built-in power supply, and resale value make this worthy of consideration.

 

I'm still debating the $200 difference between the i7 and i5.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know the BI developer recommends i7, but I don't know of anyone who's tested similarly clocked i5 vs i7 of the same generation, and nobody's said whether BI will use more than 4 threads.

 

The main differences are more cache, hyperthreading, and (sometimes) better video on the i7. The i5 3570k already has 4 cores, 6MB cache, and HD4000 graphics, so what the i7-3770k buys you is a bit more MHz, 2MB more cache, and hyperthreading (which only matters for apps using more than 4 threads).

 

As for power use, a Mini won't have any great advantage over a similarly configured PC, I believe. The main power use is the CPU, MB, and hard drive (assuming no external video card), and the only one specific to the Mini is the MB. A given CPU model running at a given % utilization will consume the same power in any system; same for a given hard drive.

 

My homebuilt i5 3570k box runs about 85W at 60% CPU, which is where it normally sits recording my 8 cams. This is with a WD Black 2TB drive, which runs about 10W. A green drive will cut that in half, though some people report issues streaming lots of video to green drives.

 

Likewise, I use the on-chip video; an external card with substantially more horsepower than the HD4000 will add at least 50W to the usage, and will go up quickly for serious graphics power.

 

ETA: Took a look at the Mac Mini specs, and they don't specify the actual i5 and i7 used, but they're definitely less powerful than the i5-3570k and i7-3770k, so you'd want to compare the specs they actually use, not the ones I list above. The i5 is a 2.5GHz dual core, which I don't even see in the Ivy Bridge lineup - is this Sandy Bridge?

 

ETA again - The i5 they use is a mobile device, so it's lower power, lower performance, and not upgradeable. It benches at about half the i5-2500 or i5-3570, so if low power use is more important than future expansion, it's certainly usable.

 

They also have a 500GB drive in the i5, and 1TB in the i7, so you might want to throw in the cost of an upgrade or an external drive.

 

The price/performance isn't looking too good for the Mini, so far. You could build a lot more power for $600...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×