Jump to content
ArtP

Triggering Alarms and a Camera Recommendation

Recommended Posts

Hi,

 

Until 30 days ago, I had no experience with IP camera's. But I am a long time network administrator by trade, so I'm baffled with only half the issues, I hope.

 

I pre-sold a surveillance solution to an existing client to cover their vacation home. One of the most important features is accurate alerting of humans via SMS/Email. I've put in many, many hours experimenting and learning, and I don't mind, as I'm very interested in offering more of these solutions and I really enjoy it.

 

I started with a couple Foscams, got rid of them, and now have a couple Hikvision 2032's. I believe I'm going to buy different camera's, as these - I don't think - are going to cut it, simply because they don't offer alarm in and out channels, neither am I thrilled there is no auto exposure control. I believe I need alarm in/out because I've given up trying to accurately alert on motion detection, outdoors, based on visible image analysis (cam or software analysis).

 

I've tried the native software the manufacturers offer, but it's horribly documented and I find it limited on features. I've also tried iSpy, Blue Iris and Synology Surveillance Station (NAS). They are all good in some areas, but none can accurate detect human motion, outdoors, with all the image changes an outdoor environment is - without false alarms. One false alarm a day is too many, and I can't even get close to that.

 

I'd like camera's that have simple, normally open or normally closed circuits to invoke alerts/alarms which afford me the ability to choose my own human detection scheme and change it later if I want. I'm looking at Bosch PIR/microwave combos, Leviton PIR/ultrasonic, pressure sensitive mats (lots of outdoor stairs), and simple magnetic switches - or a combo. Unlimited possibilities here.

 

I'm looking for a camera recommendation, for under $350 each, with the following features:

 

Auto iris, or auto exposure

Day/night - I don't mind using supplemental IR illumination

In/out alarms

PoE

Max resolution at 1920x1080, will settle at 1280x960 or 1280x720

Extra credit: Reasonably documented software

 

Am I asking too much at my price point?

 

The Dahua IPC-HDBW4300E claims to offer these features. But I can only find it at eBay, and I'm quickly tiring of Chinese stuff with no western "office" supporting it. At $165 new, seems too good to be true. The alarm the spec sheet claims is very ambiguous, there are no schematics, no photo of the interfaces, no user manual - and I don't trust the word "alarm", on their spec sheet, translates to what I expect it to mean. This being my third camera purchase, I am slightly frustrated, but I'm way more frustrated after spending 25 years knowing to avoid poorly supported Chinese garbage - I mean Chinese technology. But choices appear limited without spending $600 per camera on an Axis, or like solution. But if that's what it takes to do it right....

 

I'm totally open to suggestion if I should head in a different direction. I'm also open to paying for someone's time via email or phone, if expertise and experience command it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×